The Politics of Performance: When Legitimacy Must Be Acted

By Phalombe Jailosi, PhD

Malawi has just emerged from the Easter season; a period that, in principle, calls for reflection, sacrifice, and spiritual renewal. Yet, in the political arena, it has once again revealed something far more consequential than devotion.

It has revealed a system in which legitimacy must be performed.

Across the country, political leaders; cutting across party lines, doctrines, and personal convictions; were visibly present in churches, religious processions, and ritual observances. Some knelt. Some marched. Some carried crosses. Others quoted scripture with a fluency that would impress even seasoned clergy.

At first glance, this appears commendable. A nation whose leaders acknowledge God is, after all, a nation that recognises moral authority.

But this reading is dangerously superficial. Because what we are witnessing is not the organic expression of belief. It is the institutionalisation of performance as a condition for political acceptance.

This is why the language of performance is not incidental. It is descriptive. Many of the political figures who prominently participated in these rituals do not belong to the traditions from which these practices originate. Some come from denominations that neither emphasise nor doctrinally recognise such forms of worship, and in certain cases, explicitly discourage them. Yet, they participated; publicly, visibly, and enthusiastically; in what is largely a Roman Catholic devotional tradition. This is not a matter of ecumenical openness. It is a signal. It tells us that what is being enacted is not primarily belief, but alignment; not conviction, but recognition; not religion but politics. And when leaders cross even their own doctrinal boundaries in pursuit of public acceptance, we must confront an uncomfortable possibility: that legitimacy, in our system, is not held; it is performed.

In a stable politicojuridical order, legitimacy is embedded in institutions. Authority flows from the office, and the office is trusted because it is anchored in a shared moral and legal framework.

In such a system, a leader does not need to prove their moral worth through ritual visibility. Their legitimacy is assumed; subject, of course, to performance in office.

Malawi is not such a system. Here, legitimacy is not institutional. It is culturally negotiated. It must be continuously demonstrated, publicly affirmed, and symbolically enacted.

The result is a subtle but profound shift: Leadership is no longer merely exercised. It is staged.

This has given room to the rise of the political actor. When a system expects its leaders to perform legitimacy, it does not select for conviction. It selects for adaptability.The politician who thrives in such an environment is not the most principled, nor the most competent. It is the one most capable of reading the room; of aligning themselves, in real time, with the expectations of the electorate.

Today, it is Easter. Tomorrow, it may be a different ritual, a different symbolism, a different expectation. And the successful politician will adjust accordingly.

This is not leadership. It is political theatre.

There is a deeper danger here: one that extends far beyond seasonal religious observance. A system that rewards performance over conviction inevitably produces leaders who are externally aligned, but internally unanchored, responsive to perception, but not to principle, visible in ritual, but absent in governance

We are already seeing the consequences. Malawi’s recent electoral choices have delivered not a crisis of participation, but a crisis of presence. Leadership appears most vividly in symbolic spaces: churches, ceremonies, public gestures; while governance itself becomes increasingly hollow.

The presidency becomes distant. The machinery of state, however, remains active; particularly in areas where extraction, patronage, and self-preservation are concerned.

This is not accidental. It is the logical outcome of a system that teaches politicians that being seen is more important than being effective.

It would be easy to accuse individual politicians of hypocrisy. But that would miss the point. The real indictment is not of the actors, but of the stage.

When a political system requires its leaders to simulate legitimacy; when it compels them to demonstrate belonging through ritual rather than through governance; it reveals something fundamental about itself: It does not trust its own foundations.

A system that is legitimate does not need constant symbolic reinforcement. It does not need its leaders to kneel in public to prove their moral worth.

Only an insecure system demands continuous reassurance. Democracy, at its core, is meant to translate the will of the people into governance. But when the conditions under which that will is formed are themselves distorted, democracy becomes something else entirely.

It becomes a system in which the appearance of alignment replaces the substance of leadership, the performance of belief substitutes for the exercise of judgment, and the most effective actors, rather than the most principled leaders, rise to the top.

In such a system, elections do not necessarily produce wisdom. They produce those best able to manipulate the conditions under which the majority decides.

If Malawi is to escape this cycle, it must confront a difficult truth: The problem is not that politicians perform. The problem is that the system requires them to.

Until legitimacy is re-anchored in institutions; until authority flows from law, performance, and accountability rather than from symbolic alignment—this pattern will persist. We will continue to elect actors. We will continue to mistake visibility for virtue. And we will continue to wonder why leadership appears strongest at the altar, and weakest in the office.

Easter, in its true meaning, is a story of sacrifice, truth, and transformation. But in Malawi’s political life, it has become something else: A stage. And on that stage, our leaders perform not because they believe; but because they must.

That, more than anything else, tells us what kind of system we are living under.

By Phalombe Jailosi, PhD

zallanntata
zallanntata
Articles: 25

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *