The One Deal That Survived: A Question Malawi Must Not Ignore

Minority Report with Phalombe Jailosi, PhD, LLD

There are questions in politics that sound simple but carry within them the weight of an entire system.

Prince Kapondamgaga’s question to the Public Accounts Committee is one of them: “What made this government cancel all deals the previous government was negotiating; except this one?”

At first glance, it appears to be a question about a specific transaction. A matter of procurement, perhaps of timing, or even of administrative discretion. It is none of those things. It is a question about how power actually operates in Malawi. Because if a new administration reviews the decisions of its predecessor and chooses to cancel most of them, it is exercising what it claims to be corrective judgment. It is saying, implicitly, that those decisions were flawed, imprudent, or inconsistent with its own standards. But if, within that same exercise of review, one particular deal survives untouched, then the question is no longer administrative. It becomes structural.

What distinguishes that deal from all others? Not in law. Not in policy. But in the invisible logic of power.

A serious governance system answers such a question through process. It points to documented criteria, independent valuation, transparent review mechanisms, and clearly articulated reasons for differential treatment. But where such explanations are absent, a different explanation begins to suggest itself. Not legality. Not prudence. But proximity to power.

This is where the politicojuridical clarity becomes unavoidable. Malawi’s governance system has, over time, developed a troubling characteristic: it often appears to operate according to two parallel logics. The first is the formal logic of law and procedure. This is the logic that appears in official documents, public statements, and parliamentary debates. It is the language of policy, compliance, and regulation.

The second is the informal logic of survival and access. This is the logic that determines which decisions endure and which are reversed, which actors are protected and which are exposed, which transactions proceed and which collapse.

The difficulty is that these two logics do not always align. And when they diverge, it is the second that often prevails. Prince Kapondamgaga’s question is therefore not really asking about a deal. It is exposing the gap between these two logics.

Why is it that one agreement, among many, survives a comprehensive review? What invisible threshold did it meet? What protection does it enjoy? What relationship shields it from the fate that befell the others?

These are not questions of outrage. They are questions of institutional integrity. Because when a system cannot explain its own selectivity, it signals something far more dangerous than a bad decision. It signals structural inconsistency. And structural inconsistency is the breeding ground of distrust.

In a system governed by clear rules, decisions may be unpopular, but they are explainable. In a system governed by informal power, decisions become unpredictable, and unpredictability erodes legitimacy.

Decisions are not made solely on the basis of law or policy. They are filtered through networks of influence, obligation, and strategic protection. Some are reversed to signal reform. Others are preserved because they serve interests that transcend administrative change.

To the public, this appears as contradiction. To the system, it is simply continuity. And this is why the question cannot be allowed to fade.  Because if Malawi accepts that governance decisions can be selectively applied without clear, transparent justification, then it accepts a deeper proposition: That the system is not governed by rules, but by relationships. That power does not flow through institutions, but around them. That accountability is not a principle, but a choice. The danger of such a system is not merely corruption.

It is the gradual normalisation of arbitrariness. And once arbitrariness becomes normal, governance loses its moral foundation.

Prince Kapondamgaga’s question therefore deserves more than a procedural answer. It requires a structural response. Not an explanation of the deal itself, but an explanation of the criteria by which decisions are made, sustained, or reversed.

Until Malawi can answer that question convincingly, similar questions will continue to arise in different forms.

Why was this one protected? Why was that one pursued? Why was this one ignored?

These are not isolated inquiries. They are the recurring echoes of a system struggling to explain itself. And a system that cannot explain itself is a system whose legitimacy is already under strain.

The real issue, then, is not the deal. It is the logic that allowed it to survive.

And until that logic is brought into the open, Malawi will continue to experience governance not as a predictable system of rules, but as a sequence of decisions whose true reasoning remains just out of sight.

zallanntata
zallanntata
Articles: 25

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *