One of the most revealing moments in any governance crisis is not the scandal itself, but what happens immediately after it becomes public. It is in that moment that systems either turn toward truth; or toward narrative control.
The unfolding developments around the Amaryllis transaction present precisely such a moment.
Public concern has rightly focused on the visible actors: trustees, officials, advisors, and the technical processes that led to the decision. Parliamentary scrutiny is now beginning to unpack these layers, and early indications suggest that the factual picture may be more complex than initial public narratives allowed. Yet alongside this process, another pattern appears to be emerging; one that deserves careful attention.
In transactions of this magnitude, it is often assumed that the Board is the centre of decision-making. Yet experienced observers of governance recognise that influence can, at times, operate more decisively outside formal structures than within them—through expectation, persuasion, or pressure that leaves no official trace. In such circumstances, the Board may function as the site of formal approval, but not the source of the decision itself. The official record therefore reflects compliance with process, while the underlying dynamics that shaped the outcome remain obscured.
This may explain why there seems to be growing signs of a premature convergence toward blame.
Before the Committee has concluded its work, before its findings have been formally adopted, and before the full evidential record has been established, there are indications that responsibility is already being narrowed, and in some instances, enforcement action appears to be anticipated or initiated.
This raises a fundamental concern.
Accountability, if it is to be legitimate, must follow evidence; not precede it.
When conclusions begin to crystallise ahead of inquiry, the risk is not merely that individuals are treated unfairly. The deeper risk is that the system itself begins to protect its underlying structure by localising responsibility prematurely. In such a scenario, the question is no longer “What happened?” but rather “Who will carry it?”
This is particularly troubling in complex transactions of this nature, where decision-making is rarely linear, and where influence may not always be fully captured within formal documentation. In such environments, the visible chain of responsibility can be incomplete; not because events were simple, but because they were not.
And this brings us to the deeper issue.
In many governance systems, especially where large public resources are involved, decisions are not always confined to what is written. They are shaped through conversations, expectations, signals, and pressures that do not leave a formal trace. When such dynamics are present, the absence of documentation does not simplify the problem. It complicates it.
The absence of a complete record is not proof that nothing occurred. It is often the first indication that something occurred outside the record.
In this context, any attempt to assign responsibility exclusively to those whose names appear in the formal documentation risks missing the very dynamics that made the outcome possible. It risks producing a form of accountability that is procedurally neat; but substantively incomplete.
What is required instead is discipline.
The discipline to allow the Committee’s process to run its full course. The discipline to resist the temptation of early conclusions. And above all, the discipline to ensure that accountability reflects the full architecture of decision-making; not merely its most visible layer.
Malawi has seen moments like this before. Moments where the urgency to act overtakes the obligation to understand. Moments where outcomes are explained before they are fully examined. And each time, the result has been the same: a resolution that satisfies the moment, but leaves the system unchanged.
This must not be one of those moments.
If this inquiry is to mean anything, it must hold to a simple but demanding principle: Let the evidence speak in full; before the system decides who is responsible. Anything less risks turning accountability into performance, and inquiry into conclusion.
And when that happens, the real lesson of the scandal is not learned. It is buried.
If this inquiry is to achieve anything beyond procedural closure, it must confront these realities directly. Accountability cannot end with those who signed; it must extend to those who decided. Those who even now, are deciding. Where that distinction is ignored, the system does not correct itself. It conceals itself.





