Minority Report with Phalombe Jailosi, PhD, LLD
There is a quiet frustration that runs through Malawi. It is rarely expressed in formal language, but it is deeply felt.
Why is it that some things seem to work; briefly, partially, or in isolated pockets; while others, no matter how well designed they appear, simply never deliver? A new system is introduced. A new policy is announced. A new project is launched. On paper, everything looks right. And yet, over time, something familiar happens.
The system slows down. The policy loses direction. The project underperforms or collapses. And the public is left asking: “What went wrong?”
The answer is uncomfortable. In many cases, nothing went wrong in the way we usually think. The design was sound. The idea was borrowed from somewhere successful. The procedures were followed.
What failed was something deeper.
Malawi has become very good at creating the appearance of development. We build the structures. Institutions are established. Policies are drafted. Frameworks are adopted. Systems are launched.
On the surface, everything resembles functioning governance. We have procurement systems. We have anti-corruption bodies. We have regulatory authorities. We have development plans.
In many cases, these look almost identical to those in countries where they work. But resemblance is not reality.
The problem is not always that systems are absent. It is that they often exist in form, but not in function. A procurement system may exist, but decisions are influenced elsewhere. An oversight body may exist, but it hesitates when it matters most. A policy may be announced, but implementation quietly bends around it.
The result is a peculiar condition: Things look like they should work. But they do not. Not consistently. Not reliably. Not in a way that builds trust.
To understand this, one must recognise that governance in Malawi often operates in two parallel worlds.
The first is the official world. This is the world of laws, policies, institutions, and procedures It is visible, documented, and publicly defended.
The second is the operational world. This is the world of influence, relationships, informal decisions, and quiet adjustments It is rarely documented, but it is deeply understood by those within the system.
When these two worlds align, systems work. When they diverge, something else happens. The official system continues to exist. But the real decisions are made elsewhere.
A clear example helps to bring this into focus. Consider the kinds of major decisions that shape Malawi’s economy: large projects, fuel import arrangements, or high-value transactions such as the Amaryllis proposal. On paper, these are presented as technical or commercial decisions, guided by national need. But the uncomfortable reality is that many such decisions are not primarily driven by what the country needs, but by how they serve networks of influence around power. The logic is rarely stated openly, but it is understood in practice: who benefits, who is included, and who is protected. This is the hidden layer that explains why decisions that appear rational on paper often produce outcomes that do not serve the public interest. And until this dynamic is fully understood, Malawians will continue to judge outcomes without seeing the system that produces them.
This also explains something important. Not everything fails. Some things do work. But when they do, it is usually because, in those specific cases, the two worlds temporarily align. A competent team insists on standards. A leader chooses discipline over convenience. An institution resists interference long enough to deliver results. For a moment, the system functions as designed. But because the underlying structure has not changed, that success is difficult to sustain.
It remains the exception, not the rule.
This is why Malawians experience a recurring cycle: Hope when something new is introduced. Encouragement when early signs appear promising. Disappointment when the system gradually bends.
And eventually: Resignation. “This is how things are.” But this conclusion, while understandable, is incomplete.
The problem is not that Malawians are incapable of building working systems. It is that the systems we adopt are often not fully rooted in the way power actually operates in our society. They are designed to function in environments where rules are consistently applied, institutions act independently, and decisions follow formal processes. But they are implemented in environments where relationships influence outcomes, informal networks shape decisions, and rules can be selectively applied
The result is a mismatch. A system designed for one reality is placed into another. And the system bends.
This brings us back to the frustration with which we began. Why do some things work and others do not? Because success is not determined only by design. It is determined by whether the system is aligned with the deeper structure of power and behaviour within society.
Until that alignment is achieved, even the best-designed policies will struggle. They will look right. They will sound right. But they will not deliver consistently.
This is where the conversation must change. Malawi does not simply need more policies, more institutions, or more borrowed solutions. It needs something more fundamental: A willingness to ask whether the systems we building are truly designed for the reality in which they must operate.
That is not a question of politics. It is a question of design. And until it is confronted honestly, the pattern will continue. New systems will be introduced. They will resemble success. They will promise transformation. And over time, they will quietly become something else.
The frustration Malawians feel is not imaginary. It is perceptive. Things do not fail randomly. They fail consistently. And consistency is never an accident. It is a sign of structure.
The real challenge before Malawi is therefore not simply to do more. It is to understand more deeply why what we do does not always become what we expect. Because once that understanding is clear, a different kind of conversation becomes possible.
Not about what to copy next. But about what to build that can actually work.





